Search - Maurice Ravel, Samson Francois :: Samson Francois performs Ravel: L'oeuvre Pour Piano (2 CDs)

Ravel Piano Music If Debussy Was Playing

Doug - Haydn Fan | California | 09/06/2006

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Samson Francois has long been accorded near mythic status among many, particularly the French. His way with Ravel seems in part a throwback to the days when Ravel was considered an impressionist and his music sounded indistinquishable from that of Debussy. Vertical Harmony is here promoted to the head of the class, and the results are fascinating. This is certainly in contrast to how Ravel's music appears today: more classically inspired and horizontal than Debussy, and far less interested in abstract effects.

Thus Francois in Ravel may be a bit offsetting to anyone familiar with most modern performers of Ravel. Tempos are uniformally slower than we are used to. Francois does not downplay the melodies so much as emphasis the incidentals. Yet he is always very intellectual and patrician in his approach, thus keeping the performances from losing all formal elements and lapsing into little more than pretty piano detailings.

The great Jeux d'eau is here performed as if it were a late Debussy Prelude. Francois' approach is richly conceived with an astonishing multitude of dazzlingly and surprising changes in balance and melody from what we are used to hearing. Richter's performance of Feux d'artifice comes to mind - though Francois doesn't equal Richter's explosive fortes the Jeux d'eau does contain a like mesmerizing variety. Endless changes in form are emphasized at the expense of the piece's linearity and the listener is transfixed by the richness of poetry lurking in these playing waters. Francois was always wonderful with Gaspard de la nuit; individual moments are performed with a freedom from the classic constraints of most Ravel performances, and a never-ending series of purely Debussy-like piano effects come to dominate the usually straightforward music-making.

This horizontal sensibility runs risks - the Pavane at times calls to mind Ravel's playful reminder to a young piano student, "I wrote a Pavane for a Dead Princess, not a Dead Pavane for a Princess." But generally the slower speeds Francois adapts are forgotten as he shows off the wealth of colors and contrasts inevitably downplayed for the sake of balance. Some of this can be almost amazingly different from, say, the fine much more classic performances of Robert Casadesus. Ondine from Gaspard is over a minute longer; Une barque sur l'ocean almost two minutes longer! Although Casadesus does sometimes come in faster (the Minuets, for example) it's clear Francois felt it necessary to slow down several of the larger pieces to show them off to best advantage.

The sound of this set is less than great stereo. If you need the latest in high fidelity you might look elsewhere. No doubt Argerich in Gaspard de la nuit should be on anyone's short list of Ravel. But if you're interested in hearing Francois in a more "Debussy" style of Ravel, with the emphasis on poetics you should like this. Just remember not to wince at some of the initial tempos - in this case patience is it's own reward.



"

Samson Francois at his best

Walter Boldys | Marblehead, Massachusetts United States | 04/28/2004

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Samson Francois was at his best playing French music. His Debussy is excellent and so is this complete recording of Ravel's compositions for solo piano. "Gaspard de la nuit" was his signature piece, but the "Valses" are also amazing. The "Prelude", a very brief piece, is exquisite; it is the quintessence of Ravel's sophisticated nostalgia. There are eccenticities here, but these are extraordinary performances, embued with the artist's unique musical personality."

A piano poet !

Hiram Gomez Pardo | Valencia, Venezuela | 08/08/2004

(5 out of 5 stars)

"Ravel sounds in the hands of Samson Francois unique . The incorporean and imaginative impressionist approach of the Ondine or the nobleness of Pavana para una infante difunta for instance, or the Noble and Sentimental Waltzes are played with enigmatic approach , exquisite lyricism and sligh pianissimos giving the exact atmosphrere demanded for Federic Ravel .

Remember that Francois inherited the legitimate ravelian mood, since he was a Cortot ' s pupil .

If you like Ravel piano music and you are looking for scorching performances , this album is for you .

Francois death in 1970 when Samson was in 46 , left orphan the musical stage and his place still remains alone , pitifully ."