Search - Brahms, Hotter, Giebel :: Ein Deutsches Requiem

Sergiu Celibidache, a controversial Romanian conductor whose idiosyncratic interpretations are always fascinating, leads a moving performance of one of Brahms's greatest works. Despite slow tempos, this disc compels attention through the conductor's dynamic contrasts, unique insights, and Hans Hotter's great singing. Not to slight Agnes Geibel, a good soprano who excels in oratorio, but it's Hotter who steals the show with his glorious voice and profound understanding. The chorus and well-prepared orchestra are fine; the mono sound from a live 1957 performance, adequate. Not a first choice among recorded Brahms Requiems, but recommended to the adventurous as a supplement to the classic Otto Klemperer on EMI. --Dan Davis