Three stars is a stretch; there are some real problems here.
BebopBoomer | Virginia | 05/10/2006
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Four tracks here can be quickly discussed. #7-8 are good Marsh,if not absolutely top-drawer. Tracks 9-10 are haus-musik noodling (in pianist Sal Mosca's case,almost comically so) and should not have been released.
This leaves tracks 1-6,from a live concert in Berlin. Marsh is not in particularly good form here,although of course even mediocre Marsh beats most tenor players. Either his tone on this evening was unusually shaky,or else there is a slight wobble on the original tape source. Sal Mosca has a few good moments, but he lacks Warne Marsh's rhythmic agility or Lennie Tristano's drive,and often wrong-foots himself; he also tends to run out of ideas about half-way through his solos. Kenny Clarke and Eddy Gomez of course make a terrific rhythm section,although Clarke is perhaps too active and powerful a drummer to be ideal for this kind of music (for example, Roy Haynes on tracks 7-8 is quieter and to my mind more effective as a result).
I'm a big fan of Warne Marsh,but there are far better examples of his playing currently available on CD--"Star Highs" and "Unissued Copenhagen Recordings" to name just two."