"I loved this CD! I'm a huge and pretty critical fan of acoustic and this CD didn't dissapoint me. TSL is my fave. band so I thought Playing Favorites sounded awesome. I really liked TBS Cute Without the E, it was a really interesting take on acoustic and it was an awesome spin on a song I love, but was getting tired of. I recommened this CD to anyone who loves emo or acoustic."
Merely Okay
spookyhead | new york | 05/16/2005
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I fear that this album simply reveals that some bands are just not good stripped from the magic of the studio. More so, that many singers are simply not cut out to actually be vocalists. True, the album does have a certain amount of talented musicians and they do have good acoustic tracks, but others...well, you get the point. Purchase the album mainly for the fact that you can see what bands are actually gifted in the realm of music, and which are suited only for studio production."
Punk goes acoustic is the best
Jordan D. Honeyman | Vancouver, BC | 08/19/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Seriously, it is the best album ever. Acoustic rocks!"
Don't only judge on signing performance... Listen to the lyr
E. Marcotte | Reno, NV USA | 03/23/2006
(5 out of 5 stars)
"True, some artists give a very weak performance on this album if you only look at the signing talent. BUT, on most of the songs the lyrics are far better than anything else written in my opinion. I like the original verison of most of the songs and I'm really glad there is now an acoustic version that makes it more like a ballad. If you take time to listen to the lyrics, you'll def. like the song better than for the signing performance along (take Taking Back Sunday as an example). I must have listened to this cd about 1000 times and I still listen to it regularly."
A few Acoustic let-downs, but some good stuff in all
TheFallingStarYouNeverSaw | MO, USA | 07/26/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"So, it's not really the compiler's fault that some of the acoustic versions of much-loved songs are kind of lame. It's mostly the artists' fault for their interpretations. Yet still, with these acoustic let-downs, Punk Goes Acoustic only earns four stars. This is for fans of acoustic music; I wouldn't recommend it if you just want to hear the acoustic versions but prefer electric, because, well, this even disappointed ME and I'm a huge fan of acoustic."