Search - Matthew Dear :: Asa Breed

Unexpected.

Gary Peterson | San Diego, California USA | 11/26/2007

(4 out of 5 stars)

"Matthew Dear is an interesting and creative fellow. I own three Dear CDs and an Audion disc. He presents quite an array of musical tapestries and provides some delightful listening. I'd judge him to be one of the best "instrumental" musicians in the techno/electronica field, but I don't particularly care for his vocals. Unfortunately, his new Asa Breed disc features him as a vocalist on every track.



On the Asa Breed disc, Matthew Dear presents music that is softer, mellower and slower. Guitar, backing vocals and even some strings are added. In places, it almost sounds popish, like something you might hear on the radio. This seems like a radical departure for Dear and I had clearly expected (and hoped) he would go more in the direction of his Audion alter ego. In any case, Dear presents 13 tracks of pleasant listening music. All the tracks are good, particularly if you like somewhat mellow backgroundish music. If I had to indicate favorite tracks, mine would be "Shy," " Pom Pom," "Midnight Lovers" and "Good to be Alive." My least favorites would include "Elementary Lover," Don and Sherry" and "Give Me More."



I'm somewhat at a loss to rate this disc. I clearly enjoy Matthew Dear music. "Leave Luck to Heaven" and the Audion disc fit my musical tastes much better than the "Asa Breed" disc. Dear is such a creative fellow that I hate to damn him for a disc that I don't particularly care for. However, were I not aware of his other discs I might like this one very much. Let's just say I'm disappointed. I expected something else. Others might enjoy the disc very much. I'll give it four stars. Listen to a few tracks and use your own judgement.



Gary Peterson"

An interesting new direction weakened by sub-par vocals on e

Steward Willons | Illinois | 03/07/2008

(3 out of 5 stars)

"I'm a big Matthew Dear fan - he's making some of the most interesting minimal techno coming out of the states right now. Unfortunately, vocals are not his strong point. He's said as much himself. So that leaves the question: why do an album full of vocal tracks? The lyrics are fine - nothing amazing, but not stupid. I think the reason that Ellen Allien can do so many vocal tracks is that she has a very distinctive approach that doesn't involve a lot of straight-up "singing" - it's kind of like 3D of Massive Attack. The guy has a one octave range, but it doesn't matter because he basically whispers most of his lyrics. I think that if Dear tried for something a bit different, he'd find great success.



Enough about the vocals. The music is fine. It's a little more melodic and there isn't such an oppressive minimalist aesthetic. There's acoustic guitar on a couple tracks for crying out loud! It's definitely unexpected, but it works. The first part of the CD sounds fairly similar to "Leave Luck to Heaven" and it's not until later that things really become strange. Again, strange in a good way. As long as he keeps putting out albums as Audion as well, I'll be happy. This is good music, but I really love his minimal techno.



Asa Breed will appeal to a broader audience - not that he's necessarily trying to be more easily accessible. It's an interesting new direction. I just hope that on his next CD he leaves the vocal work to someone else."