Search - John Lennon :: Collector's Edition (Coll) (Tin)

PAT M. (Beatlesrock)
Reviewed on 5/26/2011...

Love John, Miss HIM SO MUCH!!! This has a few more of his fantastic songs that aren't on some of his other great hit collections. Highly recommended.

0 of 1 member(s) found this review helpful.

WAY short on music...questionable production.

Comic Online | Washington, DC United States | 10/10/2009

(1 out of 5 stars)

"Nearly all of these songs could have fit onto one CD. However, they decided to put only 10 songs on each disc of this compilation. Whenever you see a "box set" that has very few tracks on each disc, you should usually run, because it is not a collection assembled by the original label, and usually has shoddy production. This is no different. The song choices are ok, but it's far overpriced for the amount of music you get. It's also questionable where these masters were obtained, since Yoko has a pretty tight control on the release of her husband's music.



For an alternative, either get the remastered albums individually, or Working Hero: Definitive John Lennon Collection. It has fewer discs, but MORE MUSIC, is a remastered and authorized collection, and it COSTS LESS than this one. Don't be duped by the other fanboy review. Get a quality product at a great price, not this overpriced monstrosity."