I'm sorry, but was the below "review" really a review? Or ju
Tom Carbone | Orlando, FL | 07/29/2005
(3 out of 5 stars)
"I feel just the same as all you that wish the Punk-O-Rama series was cooler and actually put some Punk stuff on their CDS. But honestly, I gave up on this compilation series long ago.
Just stick to buying the artists CDS.
3 stars for the effort of Epitaph to make some more money. Go figure."
Not Punk. At all.
Miss Music | Never Never Land | 06/12/2006
(3 out of 5 stars)
"This cd is just not punk. Period. Not at all. It's emo/screamo at best, but some songs lean closer to pop. That being said, there are some decent bands on here: The Matches, From First To Last, Bad Religion, Dropkick Murphys, and The Unseen are the only bands that semi-save this cd.
The one thing I just can't figure out is how ANYONE can call Sage Francis's song "Sun vs. Moon" punk??? It's 100% rap, and bad rap at that. And Youth Group's "Shadowland" is about as punk as Jessica Simpson. All in all, this cd just isn't what it claims to be, and sets punk way back."