FROM A RAUCOUS ROAR to a wee whisper
Rebecca Whiting | Beautiful Bell Gardens, CA | 09/14/2005
(3 out of 5 stars)
"In this reading of "Peter and Wendy", British theater great Derek Jacobi beautifully interprets voices and inflection with impeccable timing. However, his volume varies alarmingly from one piece of dialogue or narration to the next. It's a shame that he wasn't properly coached on "radio speaking" before recording what would otherwise be a pleasing performance. Similarly, it's too bad that proper sound editing wasn't used to clean up the extreme variation.
Unfortunately, this flaw is fatal. Wherever you're listening to the recording, whether the car or the kitchen or at bedtime, you're bound barely to hear the whispers and to flinch at the shouts. Modulation on voice recordings is essential.
It's still a good performance and a good adaptation which leaves all the best bits in the story, thus the favorable star rating. Nevertheless, the recording is not worth purchasing for most listeners since better alternatives exist."