Unique and Impressive; But....
Rick Cornell | Reno, Nv USA | 02/05/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Down Beat rated this as the best vocal jazz album of 2003. Here's why I can't agree: This is a trio, with Ms. Dyer, string bass and percussion. I can't think of another album in which all (or virtually all) cuts had that instrumentation. And, this is not "Fever" with 12 variations: all the cuts have an eastern flair, and all demonstrate an almost telepathic empathy between the 3 musicians. And, though it was cut in the studio, this album could have been done live, and one gets the feeling that, if done live, the album would be exactly as it is here (plus applause). So, why knock off one star? Because there's only so much you can do with that instrumentation, if you're not going to overdub. You can't create music that will make you laugh, make you cry, make you shout, make you want to run a marathon. Not even Ann Dyer can do that. Here's an analogy: suppose Joan Miro did all of his "surrealistic squiggle" paintings in orange and purple only. It would be above average; but think what he could have accomplished if he had used the whole palette. There is nothing in this album that you will be singing in the shower within a week. But it's always interesting. With that limitation, recommended. RC
P.S.--4/6/06. This album and this review has haunted me like none other. Did I unfairly malign this album? After careful relisten, I conclude: yes and no.
Ann Dyer is a fabulous singer, and arguably is the most criminally underrated among the large universe of criminally underrated jazz singers. Her ability to bend notes and invent and reinvent lyrical lines is second only to Mark Murphy; and her ability to do that with a beautiful singing voice that is always pleasing to listen to is second to none. SHe deserves way, way more accolades than she has ever received.
But if you asked me to name two standout cuts off of this album, I couldn't do it. I can admire what Murphy does to "Green Dolphin Street", for example, because the song is so familiar; but nothing here has that degree of familiarity to act as a springboard for admiration of Ann Dyer's artistry. You have to have the patience to listen to this multiple times, before you really get it. RC"