In late 1970, shortly after his band
Matthews Southern Comfort hit number one in Great Britain with its version of
Joni Mitchell's "Woodstock,"
Ian Matthews decided that he needed more creative freedom and left for a solo career. The subsequent album, If You Saw Thro' My Eyes, his fourth and best release since leaving
Fairport Convention in 1969, was recorded and released within the next few months. It also reunited him with former
Fairport bandmates
Sandy Denny, who had left the band in late 1969, and
Richard Thompson, who would depart by the time of this album's release. Both would bring their distinctive personalities to the proceedings without ever overwhelming
Matthews' own vision. As a bandleader and songwriter,
Matthews' growth is quite evident here, guiding a stellar cast through seven excellent new originals and three well-chosen covers (also included is the a cappella "Hinge" and its instrumental reprise). Throughout,
Matthews' sweet yet evocative tenor is perfect for the material, which succeeds in its blend of British and American folk, rock, and pop. Furthermore, he once again shows a keen eye for the work of others, while also proving his prowess as a first-rate interpretive singer. A pair of songs written by the late folksinger
Richard Fariņa -- "Reno, Nevada" (resurrected from
Ian's days with
Fairport) and "Morgan the Pirate" -- are given fresh, inspired readings, highlighted by
Thompson,
Tim Renwick, and
Andy Roberts' superb guitar interplay, providing a real folk-rock edge. But it's the beautiful, prayerlike title track that is the record's crowning moment. Joined simply by
Denny's piano and breathtaking second vocal, along with a tasteful backwards guitar interlude by
Renwick,
Matthews' quiet plea for guidance is as moving and personal a song as he's ever recorded. A number of other highlights, such as "Hearts," "Southern Wind," "It Came Without Warning," and "You Couldn't Lose," make If You Saw Thro' My Eyes one of the best efforts by a
Fairport alumnus. ~ Brett Hartenbach, All Music Guide
