This CD is made up of two similarly conceived albums that were among the finest LPs
Arnold ever cut, when he was in the midst of the extended peak of his career. Cattle Call was an apparent attempt (and almost wholly successful one) to tap into the revival of interest in Western songs fostered by
Marty Robbins and
Johnny Cash at Columbia. In addition to
Arnold's re-recording (his fourth version in less than 20 years) of the title tune, in a spare but polished rendition, he also does an excellent job with
Bob Nolan's "Cool Water" and "Tumbling Tumbleweeds," the traditional "Carry Me Back to the Lone Prairie," and pieces like the singing-
cowboy anthem "Leaning on the Old Top Rail."
Grady Martin is the lead guitarist on these sessions, which were produced by
Chet Atkins and have a clean, lean sound, not overproduced and all rather similar to the sound that
Robbins got on his records. What is lacking is the tone of urgency and involvement that
Robbins brought to this same material. Thereby Hangs a Tale grew out of the
folk music boom and
Arnold's successful 1959 single of
Jimmie Driftwood's "Tennessee Stud." The Anita Kerr Singers turn up here and there, but are used in a fairly restrained manner. The stereo separation is extremely crisp and the instrumental textures are vivid throughout.
Jimmie Driftwood's original notes on Thereby Hangs a Tale have been replaced by new notes, focusing more on the songs themselves.
Chet Atkins produced both albums, but only played on Tale. ~ Bruce Eder, All Music Guide
