The titular "Mimi" of The Emancipation of Mimi is, by all accounts, an alter ego of
Mariah, a persona that captures
Carey's true feelings and emotions. In case you didn't know what "emancipation" means,
Mariah helpfully provides a dictionary definition of the word in the opening pages of the liner notes for her eighth proper album: it means "to free from restraint, control, oppression, or the power of another" or "to free from any controlling influence" or "to free somebody from restrictions or conventions." So, on The Emancipation of Mimi,
Mariah frees herself from the constraints of being herself, revealing herself to be -- well, somebody that looks startlingly like
Beyoncé, if the cover art is any indication. Mimi, or at least the sound of her emancipation, sounds remarkably like
Beyoncé, too, working a similarly sultry, low-key, polished club groove. And that's the main story of The Emancipation of Mimi: since the reserved, tasteful
adult contemporary pop of 2002's Charmbracelet failed to revive her career, she's done a 180 and returned to
r&b, in hopes that maybe this will create some excitement. It's not a bad idea, particularly because
Mariah could use
any change at this point, and it's not executed all that badly either, as all 14 tracks -- heavy on mid-tempo cuts and big
ballads, with a few harder
dance tunes featuring big-name guest rappers scattered along the way -- all follow the same deliberately smoky, late-night template. While
the Neptunes provide the best
dance cut here with "Say Somethin'" (featuring a cameo by
Snoop Dogg), especially welcome are some nice old-school '70s
smooth soul flourishes, best heard on
James Poyser's deliciously sleek "Mine Again" and such
"Big Jim" Wright productions as "I Wish You Knew" and "Fly Like a Bird." As good as those
Wright-helmed cuts are, they are also the times that the mixes slip and don't hide the flaws in
Mariah's voice, and it sounds as airy, thin, and damaged as it did on Charmbracelet, where her ragged vocals dealt a fatal blow to an already weak album. Here, apart from those
Wright tracks, the producers camouflage her voice in a number of ways, usually involving putting the groove and the sound of the production in front of the vocals. While the tunes aren't always memorable, it does make for a consistent album, one that's head and shoulders above the other LPs she's released in the 2000s, even if it doesn't compare with her glory days of the '90s. Ironically enough, a big reason why The Emancipation of Mimi doesn't sound as good as those '90s albums is that
Mariah never sounds like
herself on this record. When she's not sounding like
Beyoncé, she sounds desperate to be part of the waning bling era, dropping product placements for Bacardi, Calgon, and Louis Vuitton, or bragging about her house in Capri and her own G4, all of which sounds a little tired and awkward coming from a 35-year-old woman in her 15th year of superstardom. Disregarding these two rather sizeable problems, The Emancipation of Mimi still works, at least as a slick, highly crafted piece of
dance-pop -- it might not be as hip as it thinks it is, nor is it as catchy as it should be, but it's smooth and listenable, which is enough to have it qualify as a relative comeback for "Mimi"
Carey. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine, All Music Guide
