Released in 1995, Dear You found
Jawbreaker cleaning up and streamlining their
punk-pop sound and coming up with a sleek, slick
punk-
grunge classic that relies as much on clever songwriting and restrained emotions as it does on the group's trademarked high-energy attack. From the opening chords of the anthemic "Save Your Generation,"
Blake Schwarzenbach's vocals are the star. He was coming off of throat surgery that robbed him of a lot of his vocal power, but gave him a smoky intimate sound that gives the feeling that he is whispering right in your ear. On songs like "I Love You So Much It's Killing Us Both" and "Jet Black," he sounds wounded in a way that screaming could never convey. The album is a powerful mix of jumpy
punk-pop like "Bad Scene Everybody's Fault," "Fireman," and the aching "Chemistry," and midtempo tracks like the amazing "Jet Black," "Million," and "Basilica," which escape being tied to the time of
grunge-by-the-numbers by being melodic and heartfelt without going over the top, by being just
punk enough to be real and just epic enough to rise above the often boringly earnest approach of too many
punk bands. Along with
Weezer's Blue Album, Dear You is one of the cornerstones upon which
emo and late-'90s
punk-pop was built. Certainly
Jimmy Eat World wore out their copy (Bleed American sounds like a less-produced younger brother), and
Dashboard Confessional's whole oeuvre sounds like a lesser version of Dear You's acoustic "Unlisted Track." Depending on how you feel about
emo, there is either a lot to blame them for or be thankful for here. Either way, Dear You is one of the best rock records of the '90s and a fitting last testament to a great band. [The 2004 reissue of Dear You adds five songs recorded at the same sessions for Dear You: the creepy "Shirt," a pounding cover of
the Psychedelic Furs' "Into You Like a Train," the slightly generic "Sister," the powerful ballad "Friendly Fire," and the short, very catchy "Boxcar." The songs add a nice postscript to a great album -- nothing revelatory but all very pleasant.] ~ Tim Sendra, All Music Guide
