The performers on this recording, whom
Georg Solti instructed, "Please play and sing as if you were performing
Brahms!" clearly took his directions to heart. This performance is characterized by the kind of passion, and occasional frenzy,
Schoenberg had in mind -- in this incarnation, the
opera could never be taken as an academic exercise in serialism. A large part of the credit goes to
Solti, who discovers the dramatic contours within the musical phrases and delivers a shapely and nuanced reading. The
opera's punch is heightened by the composer's brilliantly colorful and evocative orchestration, which creates a drama of its own, and the
Chicago Symphony plays with considerable heat without sacrificing precision. Whether or not
Schoenberg's harmonic language is to a listener's personal taste, it would be hard not to get caught up in the visceral energy of the performance. The chorus is really the star of the
opera, and the
Chicago Symphony Chorus, directed by the legendary
Margaret Hillis, sings the grueling music with the apparent ease and naturalness one would expect in a performance of a tonal piece. In the dramatically challenging role of Moses,
Franz Mazura delivers the
Sprechstimme lines with real authority and power. Tenor
Philip Langridge's voice is not always tonally beautiful -- the upper register can sound strained -- but he sings with passion and understanding, and his Aron is a strong dramatic foil to
Mazura's stern Moses. Soprano
Barbara Bonney and bass
Aage Haugland bring a sheen of bel canto polish to their relatively small roles. Decca's sound, in this reissue of a 1984 release, is warm and dramatically realistic. ~ Stephen Eddins, All Music Guide