A few months after he suddenly found himself transformed from an unknown independent artist into a U.K. Top Ten star by the single "How Wonderful You Are,"
Gordon Haskell released this highlight compilation in an attempt to introduce his new fans to his extensive back catalog. All My Life spans a decade-long solo career, and it demonstrates that
Haskell didn't always record in the barebones settings that made Harry's Bar and its monster hit, "How Wonderful You Are," so effective. Turns out
Haskell used a lot of electric guitar and synthesizer in days gone by, with widely varying results. On "Hambledon Hill,"
Haskell exercises restraint and uses light
electronic backing to add an air of mystery to the pretty melody. On "Mumbo Jumbo," he brews an intriguing
new wave-tinted
afro-pop arrangement that sounds something like
Billy Joel meets
Juluka. But the title track is just about destroyed by a twinkly
easy listening synth and sax backing.
Haskell always straddles a fine line between inventive light
jazz-
folk and irredeemably gooey
easy listening, but the rancid-sweet arrangements on tracks like "All My Life" and "Chilli Chilli" push him way over into the Muzak camp. Only "Please Don't Try to Talk to Me" and "Nothing in This World" apply the ice cool guitar-and-vocal Harry's Bar approach, and the result is that
Haskell's fine vocals (which have improved tremendously with age thanks to their relaxed self-possession and compellingly textured husk) are often lost in the mix. This retrospective is a very mixed bag, but the good news is that the best seems yet to come. ~ Evan Cater, All Music Guide
