It's tempting to dismiss
D12's debut album, Devil's Night, as exploitative juvenilia, similar to how fellow Detroit
hardcore rap acts such as
ICP and
Esham had been treated in the past. In fact, it's hard
not to dismiss this album as shock
rap because that's exactly what it is -- there's no denying it. As witty as
Eminem may be -- and he's by far the most creative member of the group -- the countless forays into theatrical perversity far outnumber the more literate moments. But to dismiss the album strictly because of its themes would be unfortunate. As challenging as it may be for many to stomach the constant and incredibly explicit sex, violence, and drug references, there is a stunning album lurking beneath that deserves recognition. Functioning as the album's executive producer and as the producer for most of the album's beats,
Eminem has done a wonderful job crafting this album and its foreboding feel. Influenced by the style of sparse beats
Dr. Dre employed on
Eminem's past solo hits, the troublemaking MC's beatmaking steals the show here, particularly on the album's standout moment, "Purple Pills." In fact,
Eminem's beats often contest the couple equally impressive tracks that
Dre contributes. Besides the remarkable production,
Eminem also showcases his songwriting genius on several of the song's hooks, bringing a catchy
pop-rap approach to hardcore lyrics. Yet no matter how accomplished this album is from a production and songwriting angle, it's impossible to look past the disturbing lyrics, especially those of
Bizarre, and also
Eminem's moments of unnecessary instigation. This album is obviously targeting those with a taste for perversity. If that means you, then you'll love this; if that doesn't mean you, then the album is still worth investigating, if only for
Eminem's show-stealing performance as not only an MC but also as an adept producer and songwriter. ~ Jason Birchmeier, All Music Guide
