Dan Penn is one of the great Southern soul songwriters, and
Irma Thomas is one of the great soul singers, so devoting an entire album to
Penn songs was a good idea. Actually,
Penn didn't so much write the material as co-write it; he composed every track with one or more co-writers, with
Thomas herself getting in on the act on a couple. Four of the 13 tunes are actually interpretations of songs that have been around for a long time (such as "I'm Your Puppet" and "Woman Left Lonely"), but otherwise they were done specifically for this album. So is the result godhead? No, though it's okay.
Thomas sings very well -- it's been pretty rare that she
hasn't sung well, on anything -- and has a good sense of staying within herself where a lot of singers would over-emote, as on "If You Want It, Come and Get It." Recorded in Memphis (noted frequent
Penn associate
Spooner Oldham plays keyboards on several cuts), there's a laid-back modern soul feel that gets too laid back at times and not fiery on enough occasions. It's respectable modern soul, slicker than purists would like, but not annoyingly so. The newly written songs are alright, but again not amazing.
Thomas' vocals are the highlight, as they should be. ~ Richie Unterberger, All Music Guide
