Coleman Hawkins was always
Ben Webster's idol. They finally shared a record date on October 16, 1957, and it was reissued as half of this two-LP set. With the backing of the
Oscar Peterson Trio plus drummer
Alvin Stoller,
Webster and
Hawk match wits and ideas on seven standards and two of
Hawkins's originals.
Webster was really no match for the elder tenor (and he knew it), particularly harmonically (
Hawk was a master of chords), but he had the advantage of a huge emotional tone. Although
Hawkins wins honors, it is not a runaway. The second album also features the two tenor greats plus the tenor of
Budd Johnson, trumpeter
Roy Eldridge, and a four-piece rhythm section.
Webster wrote three songs for the date (including tributes to
Hawk and
Budd), and there is a 20-minute version of "In a Mellow Tone" to wrap up the proceedings. The results are a deadheat except on "Time After Time" where
Webster's beautiful sound is well-featured. Recommended. ~ Scott Yanow, All Music Guide