"I enjoy good electronica as much as the next person, but listening to this album was a painful experience. What a way to ruin perfectly good songs! Besides, do we really need a different version of "Fitter Happier"?
Even if you are a die-hard Radiohead fan (which I am), you should stay away from this CD, especially if you didn't really care for Kid A (which I did). On second thought, you should stay away from this IF you're a Radiohead fan! Only tracks that are even remotely tolerable are Creep, Climbing the Wall and Fake Plastic Trees.
Pretty please, with sugar on top, don't just buy this because they are Radiohead covers. Do yourself a favor and listen to the samples first. You'll thank me later."
Open-minded radiohead fans: get it!!!
01javo | Caracas, VENEZUELA | 10/28/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"This CD contains electronic versions of many radiohead songs. If you consider buying it, remember not to expect Radiohead-like versions of Radiohead songs. THAT WOULDN'T MAKE SENSE. many reviewers complain that "it doesn't sound like radiohead" WELL OF COURSE NOT! IT'S NOT RADIOHEAD! If I want to listen to Radiohead-like songs,, I'd buy Radiohead albums!!! I think it is an awesome album, then again, I like both radiohead and electronic music. I like all of the tracks, specially Paranoid Android, the beat fits the song perfectly. The slow creep version makes you look at the song from a different point of view. Fake plastic trees with female vocals adds an angelical touch to the song. The moog-bassed version of Climbing up the walls is another of the great tracks of the cd. All in all... If you like the last couple of radiohead albums, I don't see why you wouldn't like Plastic Mutations. I highly reccomend it. Listen to the samples so you understand what I mean!!"
Pants on a particularly splintery stick
mcbat | 08/02/2001
(1 out of 5 stars)
"It's utterly awful. On the plus side some are so bad (especially some of the singing, oh boy) that they're quite funny. Until you remember you just paid actual cash for this. Feck."
Tighter Restrictions; Better Tributes
N. Taba | Woodland Hills, CA United States | 06/26/2001
(1 out of 5 stars)
"This has to be one of the worst "tribute" albums I have ever purchased. Most of it consists of instrumental dance tracks. How disturbing is it to take the songs of one of today's most gifted songwriters and then desecrate them by just playing a few pad sweeps over an out-of-the-box trance beat, whilst engaging in realtime tweaking of one's own sampled voice? Nonsense. This album is as a good a reason as any to place tighter restrictions on the sale of electronic musical equipment. One should be required to demonstrate a modicum of musical taste before being allowed to leave the store with sequencing software and a sound module. The only song worth listening to on this compilation is possibly the "Fake Plastic Trees" cover. The worst track on this album (of the many terrible ones) is the "Everything In Its Right Place" cover. Please. Give me a break. . . ."
One star is VERY generous - Garbage Mutations
Todd P. Wimer | West Chester, PA | 11/19/2002
(1 out of 5 stars)
"This CD is aurally repugnant. Each time I listen to it I dislike it more and more. I love Radiohead and I dig electronic music, so I figured this CD would be great. The idea has potential, electronic remixes of Radiohead's infinitely remixable music, but flops. Poorly done. Hard to listen to. Some of the synths sound like an 8-bit Nintendo system when it freezes up. Great soundtrack for a headache. I could go on and on. Please don't support the profanation of Radiohead with this audio ...!"